HomeSpoonThey Want My Soul
They Want My Soul
Rock · 2014 · 20 tracks · 1h 15m

They Want My Soul

A brilliant collision of Spoon's signature rhythmic precision and Dave Fridmann's blown-out, psychedelic production. Warm, cosmic, and incredibly sharp.

Find on Amazon

Cosmic expansion

A dry snare cracks through a haze of shimmering keyboards, pulling a lean, rhythmic swagger into focus. This is a sound caught between tight, physical grooves and a strange, cosmic warmth that bleeds at the edges. The guitars are sharp and clipped, but the air around them feels heavy, saturated, and slightly blown out. You are listening to a band finding a looser, weirder kind of confidence, trading their usual minimalist chill for something that glows in the dark.

They Want My Soul · vs · Spoon
Confident+1.3σ

The band trades their usual nervous tension for a swaggering, late-night confident stride that anchors the record in a cool, unflappable groove.

Tracklist · 20 Tracks · 1h 15m
01
Rent I Pay
3:09
01
Rent I Pay
3:09
02
Inside Out
5:02
02
Inside Out
5:02
03
Rainy Taxi
3:58
03
Rainy Taxi
3:58
04
Do You
3:33
04
Do You
3:33
05
Knock Knock Knock
4:39
05
Knock Knock Knock
4:39
06
Outlier
4:22
06
Outlier
4:22
07
They Want My Soul
3:22
07
They Want My Soul
3:22
08
I Just Don’t Understand
2:38
08
I Just Don’t Understand
2:38
09
Let Me Be Mine
3:26
09
Let Me Be Mine
3:26
10
New York Kiss
3:27
10
New York Kiss
3:27
Moments Worth Waiting For
02Inside OutThe skeletal groove of 'Inside Out' is carried by a cascading, harp-like synthesizer loop and a deep, booming bass drum.
01Rent I PayOn 'Rent I Pay', the drum track is heavily saturated and pushed to the absolute front of the mix, creating a massive, stomping rhythm.
The album marks the debut of keyboardist Alex Fischel, whose electronic textures reshape the band's guitar-centric foundation.
Sits BesideSee all
Gimme Fiction
Gimme Fiction
Spoon
2005

Shares vocal_layering, art rock, indie rock, indie pop (vocal style)

Kintsugi
Kintsugi
Death Cab for Cutie
2015

Shares art rock, indie rock, indie pop, alternative rock (subgenre)

Ropewalk
Ropewalk
The View
2015

Shares keys/synth, vocal_layering, art rock, indie rock (signature)

Flood
Flood
Hippo Campus
2024

Shares art rock, indie rock, indie pop, dusk (subgenre)

Hot Sun Cool Shroud
Hot Sun Cool Shroud
Wilco
2024

Shares art rock, indie rock, dusk, alternative rock (subgenre)

Abandonic
Abandonic
Grimus
2022

Shares vocal_layering, art rock, indie rock, dusk (vocal style)

Red Light Syndrome
Red Light Syndrome
Pluto
2001

Shares keys/synth, art rock, indie rock, alternative rock (signature)

Dream of Reason
Dream of Reason
The Cairos
2014

Shares vocal_layering, dreamy, indie rock, indie pop (vocal style)

Descended Like Vultures
Descended Like Vultures
Rogue Wave
2005

Shares dreamy, indie rock, indie pop, tape_saturation (mood)

Young the Giant
Young the Giant
Young the Giant
2010

Shares art rock, indie rock, indie pop, alternative rock (subgenre)

Reviews
Critic Consensus

Widely praised for its polished production and vibrant energy, the album was warmly received by critics who admired how it expands the band's signature style into a more eclectic, larger-scale direction. Reviewers celebrated the crisp songwriting and cool, inviting atmosphere, noting that the group beautifully refines their distinct sound with a focused yet expansive presence.

Under the Radar
“Clearly, those searching for something new are better off looking elsewhere. But if it’s dependable melodies and soaring choruses you’re after, then They Want My Soul is an album you can count on”
Read review
The Guardian4/ 5 stars
“It promises much but never quite delivers”
Read review
Clash
“The band’s dependable grasp of instantly joyous hooks still shows no sign of deserting them”
Read review
Spin8/ 10
“Soul achieves the nearly impossible with Spoon’s most eclectic set yet”
Read review
PopMatters
“It’s another strong record from the band, one that pushes forward in interesting ways while still staying rooted in Spoon’s signature sound”
Read review
Rolling Stone4/ 5 stars
“Spoon have always done surprisingly well on their own terms, in their own world. And that world sounds bigger and brighter than ever”
Read review
Drowned in Sound
“Flits from piano-lead stomp (‘Rainy Taxi’) to reflective organ-flecked peons (‘Outlier’) almost on a whim”
Read review
Paste
“Throughout They Want My Soul, the songs flow into and out of each other with a subtle movement that’s hypnotic and sounds deceptively simple”
Read review
Pitchfork8.6/ 10
“The quintet’s most booming LP, eons ahead of their Pixies-worshipping beginnings and a far cry from the relatively small-scale charm of their early-2000s touchstones Girls Can Tell and Kill the Moonlight”
Read review
Uncut
“The production builds a rich emotional topography for the songs”
Read review
AllMusic4/ 5 stars
“More of a welcome return than a comeback, and too complex to be considered back-to-basics - especially when they reinvent the basics on each album”
Read review
Exclaim!
“A bold and swaggering declaration that Spoon have undoubtedly still got it — in spades”

Cassette uses generative AI to enrich its catalog. How we use AI →