It Was Good Until It Wasn’t

Released during the height of the 2020 global lockdowns, 'It Was Good Until It Wasn’t' represents a pivotal maturation in Kehlani’s discography. Moving away from the sunny, Oakland-centric vibrancy of 'SweetSexySavage', this project embraces a darker, more cynical 'trap-soul' aesthetic. The album was largely completed in home studios, which contributes to its dry, intimate vocal presence and focused thematic arc. Critics, including those at AllMusic, noted the album's sophisticated songwriting and its ability to balance contemporary R&B trends with a timeless, soulful vulnerability. The project is notable for its use of skits and interludes (featuring Megan Thee Stallion and Jhené Aiko) that provide a narrative framework of navigating public perception versus private reality. It stands as a definitive document of R&B in the early 2020s, prioritizing atmosphere and emotional honesty over radio-ready singles.