HomeElliott SmithEither/Or
Either/Or
Singer-Songwriter · 1997 · 12 tracks

Either/Or

A masterwork of hushed, double-tracked vocals and intricate acoustic guitar. It captures the heavy, beautiful isolation of a Portland winter in a basement studio.

Find on Amazon

Critical peak

Double-tracked vocals whisper through the hiss of a four-track tape, transforming a freezing Portland basement into a sanctuary of devastating precision. This is the exact pivot where lo-fi solitude hardened into timeless, intricate chamber pop. By balancing the raw, bruised intimacy of his earliest home recordings with a newfound, brilliant melodic ambition, he perfected a fragile dialect of beautiful isolation. You are pulled into a quiet, suffocating room where every acoustic fingerpick carries the weight of a sudden departure. It remains the definitive monument of his catalog, the precise moment a private ache became a universal language.

Either/Or · vs · Elliott Smith
Analog Warmth+1.1σ

A rich analog warmth envelops these recordings, elevating the home-recorded four-track hiss into a golden, tape-saturated glow that wraps around the listener like a heavy wool blanket.

Tracklist · 12 Tracks
01
Speed Trials
3:01
02
Alameda
3:43
03
Ballad of Big Nothing
2:48
04
Between the Bars
2:21
05
Pictures of Me
3:47
06
No Name No. 5
3:43
07
Rose Parade
3:28
08
Punch and Judy
2:26
09
Angeles
2:57
10
Cupid’s Trick
3:05
11
2:45 AM
3:19
12
Say Yes
2:19
Moments Worth Waiting For
04Between the BarsThe hushed, circular acoustic pattern on 'Between the Bars' creates a private, late-night space that feels almost voyeuristic.
09AngelesOn 'Angeles', the dizzying speed of the fingerpicking pattern acts as the primary rhythmic engine, mimicking a frantic heartbeat.
03Ballad of Big NothingThe sudden arrival of a full drum kit and electric bass on 'Ballad of Big Nothing' signals a major expansion in sonic scale.
12Say YesThe album closes with 'Say Yes', a rare moment of melodic optimism carried by a bright, multi-tracked vocal arrangement.
Sits BesideSee all
All the Rage
All the Rage
Cary Brothers
2004

Shares autumn_walk, indie folk, chamber pop, whispered (atmosphere)

XO
XO
Elliott Smith
1998

Shares autumn_walk, indie folk, chamber pop, whispered (atmosphere)

2019
2019
Lucy Dacus
2019

Shares autumn_walk, indie folk, chamber pop, indie rock (atmosphere)

Dressed Up Like Nebraska
Dressed Up Like Nebraska
Josh Rouse
1998

Shares lonely, autumn_walk, indie folk, whispered (mood)

Waters Ave. S.
Waters Ave. S.
Damien Jurado
1997

Shares lonely, autumn_walk, indie folk, indie rock (mood)

minor
minor
Gracie Abrams
2020

Shares lonely, indie folk, chamber pop, whispered (mood)

Vacancy
Vacancy
Joseph Arthur
1999

Shares lonely, indie folk, chamber pop, whispered (mood)

Heavyweight
Heavyweight
Rachael Yamagata
2012

Shares indie folk, chamber pop, whispered, indie rock (subgenre)

Woke Myself Up
Woke Myself Up
Julie Doiron
2007

Shares indie folk, whispered, indie rock, vulnerable (subgenre)

11:11
11:11
Maria Taylor
2005

Shares autumn_walk, indie folk, chamber pop, whispered (atmosphere)

Reviews
Critic Consensus

Critics were widely enthusiastic, and the album drew broad acclaim.

Spin7/ 10
Read review
The Rolling Stone Album Guide3.5/ 5 stars
Read review
Pitchfork8.8/ 10
NME8/ 10
The Irish Times4/ 5 stars
Read review
Chicago Tribune3.5/ 4 stars
Read review
AllMusic4.5/ 5 stars
Read review

Cassette uses generative AI to enrich its catalog. How we use AI →