Both Directions at Once: The Lost Album — John Coltrane

This album feels like unearthing a hidden chamber in a grand cathedral: familiar yet profoundly new. It's the sound of Coltrane's legendary Classic Quartet at a crucial juncture, caught in the act of creation, pushing boundaries even as they refined their already iconic sound.

Expect intricate, searching saxophone lines, McCoy Tyner's resonant piano chords, Jimmy Garrison's unwavering bass, and Elvin Jones's explosive, propulsive drumming.

It's intense, spiritual, and deeply contemplative, offering a raw, unfiltered glimpse into the mind of a jazz titan. This is essential listening for anyone seeking to understand the evolution of modern jazz and the boundless depths of Coltrane's genius.

Moments Worth Listening For

The explosive, almost telepathic interplay between Coltrane's tenor saxophone and Elvin Jones's polyrhythmic drumming during the faster tempo tracks, showcasing the quartet's unparalleled synergy.

McCoy Tyner's signature, harmonically rich piano voicings and cascading solos, particularly how they build tension and release, providing a grounding yet adventurous counterpoint to Coltrane's flights.

Jimmy Garrison's remarkably steady and inventive double bass lines, which anchor the quartet even during its most abstract explorations, providing a deep rhythmic and harmonic foundation.

The distinct shift in timbre and mood when Coltrane switches to soprano saxophone, offering a more piercing and lyrical voice that foreshadows his later spiritual works.

Reviews

Also reviewed byAllMusic

Where This Album Departs

How does Both Directions at Once: The Lost Album sound next to the rest of John Coltrane's catalogue?

This album stays in step with the catalogue across the board — no axis departs enough to be worth its own note. Hover the dots to see where each one sits.

Cassette uses generative AI to enrich its catalog. How we use AI →